Car damages

Judge Alex

EPISODE VITALS

  • Show Judge Alex
  • Date Added Jan 19, 2018
  • Season 4
  • Episode 1
  • Ruling in favor of plaintiff
Amount of ruling: $4500
WATCH EPISODE

QUICK OVERVIEW

Plaintiff is suing for car damages, $3700. Defendant is countersuing for car damages, $506.

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

Defendant owns a Limo company. Plaintiff claims defendants driver backed into her car. Defendant claims that plaintiff caused the accident. Per plaintiff the driver admitted it was his fault as hi backed up on the red light, defendant denies the claim, she says the driver has an impeccable driving record and is very honest and reliable. Per plaintiff defendant fired the driver, she had communication with him, he was fired because of the accident, plaintiff denies it, says the driver left the company as he was part time only and they knew that before the accident. Plaintiff claims that the officer said the damages in the car were existing. According to the police report the driver said that he backed the car and did not see the defendant; but, later on the driver changed his testimony on a sworn statement saying that is not accurate, do to the language barrier he must have been misunderstood, defendant showed affidavit. Judge was able to track down the driver, as he expects to talk to the witness, he gave a statement to the Judge saying that he did back up, it was his fault, and the owner of the Limo Company made him say otherwise on a later statement.

ABOUT Judge Alex

Cuban-born Alex Ferrer -- a former police officer, trial attorney and criminal court judge -- presides over a charged courtroom where he hears landlord disputes, complaints from consumers and other small-claims cases.

ABOUT THE PLAINTIFF

plaintiff
Tonya Moore

ABOUT THE DEFENDANT

defendant
Patricia Stephenson

Owner of a Limo Company

judge plaintiff defendant bailiff judge defendant plaintiff courtroom defendant evidence evidence judge defendant

Comment (3)

  • image

    The POS defendant is a real piece of work. Even after it's proven her entire defense is a lie - she says Judge Alex sided with the Plaintiff because she's "a single mom who doesn't have any income"! She had to give one final dig, as an insult - as if she's better than the Plaintiff.?

    Reply
  • image

    I can just tell that the company owner is a bitch to work for. She's a manipulative, self serving nasty shrew. One thing that really struck me is her first statement about her driver, saying that he's Russian or a foreigner. There was a very superior tone and attitude (at least, that's how she came off to me.) Props to the driver for being an honest, stand up man.?

    Reply
  • image

    She is without a conscience, trying to screw around a young girl and fires employee for doing right thing. Shows you what business people are like. It's always about the money even when she has no problem affording to pay damages. It's most likely her insurance rates she's worried about ,it's certainly not people .?

    Reply
  • image

    Im glad the driver owned up and told the truth to both the police and the court clerk :3 He sounds nice based on that statement. I think she forged his "amended" police statement. Nice to know theirs some honesty in the world

    Reply
  • image

    The name of her company ours is Executive Limo Service in Pasadena California. Everyone should write a Yelp review giving their opinion of this case?

    Reply
  • image

    Strange that Ms Stevenson, the limo owner, was allowed to testify at all since she was not present at the accident.?

    Reply

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *