Car damages

Judge Alex

EPISODE VITALS

  • Show Judge Alex
  • Date Added Jan 19, 2018
  • Season 4
  • Episode 1
  • Ruling in favor of defendant
Amount of ruling: $1055
WATCH EPISODE

QUICK OVERVIEW

Plaintiff is suing for car damages, $3000. Defendant is countersuing for car damages, $1055.

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

Plaintiff claims defendant damaged her car when towing it. Defendant claims that plaintiffs witness damaged his tow truck, he was legally towing plaintiff car when the witness assaulted him and damaged his truck. Evidence showed that plaintiff was illegally parked. Evidence showed footage of the violent encounter. While hooking the car in the towing truck defendant claims he was assaulted by witness, who is plaintiffs roommate, he managed to get out of there on the street. Judge ruled in favor of the defendant.

ABOUT Judge Alex

Cuban-born Alex Ferrer -- a former police officer, trial attorney and criminal court judge -- presides over a charged courtroom where he hears landlord disputes, complaints from consumers and other small-claims cases.

ABOUT THE PLAINTIFF

plaintiff
Karen Vaughn

ABOUT THE DEFENDANT

defendant
James McClain

plaintiff plaintiff defendant courtroom courtroom courtroom plaintiff defendant evidence evidence defendant witness bailiff evidence evidence witness evidence plaintiff plaintiff evidence judge evidence witness

Comment (3)

  • image

    emtb9111

    Nov 19, 2017

    Let's see here, how many people think it is a good idea to park in a fire lane? If you are not a fire truck, you don't belong there!?

    Reply
  • image

    Elaine Barney

    Nov 19, 2017

    The plaintiffs are two wanna-be's that have no respect for others...they think if they are loud and bitchy they will get over....the fat male finds his his own actions funny...NOT...he needs to look in that mirror...doesn't look like he was punched hard enough! Hope the complex manager calls the towers every time they park there...365...?

    Reply
  • image

    Jennifer Rathwell

    Oct 19, 2017

    His cheek looks like that not swollen. I'm glad the defendant won the case. The plaintiffs are so stupid. They were parked in a fire lane HELLO stupid much?

    Reply
  • image

    ucnhtmenow1

    Dec 31, 1969

    I'm sure it's different in each state but if it's private property or a residential area, don't they have to receive a call before they can tow someone's vehicle? It's not like downtown where parking enforcement is actually looking for infractions. The drop fee is such bullshyt. Some tow truck drivers will literally raise the car as fast as they can, even if you get there in time, just so you have to pay the "drop fee". Towing cars is such a scandalous game.?

    Reply

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Court Shows